Bricks vs. Foyer Savings
Both help renters save for a home. One invests your money. The other doesn't.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Bricks | Foyer Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Investment account (REITs) | Savings account |
| Returns | ~8% avg (historical REIT returns) | 3.33% APY (Foyer+) / 0.67% (Basic) |
| Deposit match | N/A | 6% (Foyer+) / 3% (Basic) |
| Monthly cost | $5/month | Free or $99/year (Foyer+) |
| SIPC/FDIC | SIPC-insured up to $500k | FDIC-insured (via partner bank) |
| Tax loss harvesting | Yes | No |
| Bank connection | Plaid | Not disclosed |
| Risk | Market fluctuation | None |
| Best for | 2+ year timeline | Under 1 year timeline |
The Core Difference: Investing vs. Saving
Foyer is a savings account with a marketing angle. The 6% deposit match sounds compelling, but it's capped and requires the $99/year Foyer+ plan to access. At 3.33% APY, your money grows slowly.
Bricks invests your money into diversified REITs. Historically, REITs have returned ~8% annually. Your money doesn't just sit there. It works in real estate alongside the properties you're saving to buy.
Let's Do the Math
Here's what $500/month looks like over 5 years across each option:
Foyer Savings (3.33% APY)
~$32,800
Foyer+ with 6% match
~$34,100
After $495 in fees
Bricks (8% avg return)
~$36,700
~$2,600 more than Foyer+
That's roughly $2,600 more with Bricks, and this gap widens significantly over longer periods. Run your own numbers with our Down Payment Timeline Calculator.
When to Choose Foyer
If you're buying within 12 months and want zero risk, a savings account makes sense. Foyer's deposit match adds a small bonus on top. If your timeline is short, preserving capital matters more than growth.
Foyer is also a reasonable option if you prefer the simplicity of a savings account and don't want any exposure to market fluctuations. For very short timelines, the predictability is valuable.
When to Choose Bricks
If your timeline is 2 or more years, investing historically outperforms savings accounts significantly. The longer your timeline, the bigger the advantage. Tax loss harvesting provides additional value by reducing your tax bill each year.
Your money grows with the real estate market, keeping pace with rising home prices. This is important because while you're saving, home prices often keep climbing. A savings account earning 3% can't keep up with a housing market that has historically appreciated faster than that.
Ready to invest in your future home?
Bricks automatically invests for your future home. Join the waitlist for early access.
About Foyer Savings
Foyer is a fintech company (not a bank) that offers savings accounts through Pacific West Bank. They provide a deposit match program and a higher APY for paid members through their Foyer+ plan. The company was founded to help renters save for homeownership.
Deposits are FDIC-insured through their partner bank. Foyer offers a free tier with 0.67% APY and a 3% deposit match, as well as the Foyer+ plan at $99/year with 3.33% APY and a 6% deposit match.