Bricks vs. High-Yield Savings Accounts
A HYSA protects your money. Bricks grows it.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Bricks | HYSA |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Investment account (REITs) | Savings account |
| Returns | ~8% avg (historical REIT) | 4-5% APY (variable) |
| Growth | Compound investment returns | Interest on balance |
| Keeps pace with home prices (3-5%/yr) | Yes | Barely |
| Tax advantages | Tax loss harvesting | Interest is taxable income |
| Protection | SIPC up to $500k | FDIC up to $250k |
| Risk | Market fluctuation | None |
| Fees | $5/month | Usually none |
| Best for | 2+ year timeline | Under 1 year or emergency fund |
The Core Difference
HYSAs are great products. 4-5% is real money. But home prices rise 3-5% per year. A HYSA barely keeps pace, meaning your purchasing power stays flat.
Investing gives your down payment a chance to actually grow faster than the market you're saving to enter. With ~8% historical REIT returns, your money works in real estate alongside the properties you're saving to buy.
Let's Do the Math
Here's what $500/month looks like over 5 years across each option:
HYSA at 4.5% APY
~$33,800
Bricks (8% avg return)
~$36,700
~$2,900 more with Bricks
The Difference
~$2,900
Extra toward your down payment
That gap widens significantly over longer periods. Run your own numbers with our Down Payment Timeline Calculator.
When to Choose a HYSA
If you're buying within 12 months and need guaranteed preservation of capital, a HYSA is the right call. It's also the best place for your emergency fund or any money you cannot afford to lose in the short term.
No shame in a HYSA. It's a solid choice for short timelines. If you are very risk-averse and prioritize certainty over growth, a HYSA gives you predictable returns with zero downside.
When to Choose Bricks
If your timeline is 2 or more years, you want your money working in real estate, and you want tax loss harvesting benefits, Bricks is built for you. Investing historically outperforms savings accounts significantly over longer periods.
If you're comfortable with market fluctuation in exchange for higher expected returns, investing gives your down payment the best chance to grow faster than rising home prices.
Ready to invest in your future home?
Bricks automatically invests for your future home. Join the waitlist for early access.